View Single Post
Old November 13th, 2007   #3 (permalink)
Brian Smith
Veteran Member
 
Brian Smith's Avatar
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Sarasota, FL
Age: 36
Posts: 1,081

Name: Brian Smith


United_States 


Default Re: Max 2008 and Autodesk Claim for performance enhancements

Quote:
Originally Posted by Jefferson Grigsby View Post
Those of you who have worked in complicated scenes imported from ADT, Revit, AutoCAD, have likey been giddy about autodesks claims that Max 2008 will manage complicated scenes more efficiently. When I say complicated scene, I am not talking about polygon count, but the number of actual pieces of geometry in a scene. If you have 12000 cubes in a scene, Max 9 would hang up at render time and the real time display would choke. Attach all of those objects into one, still the same number of poly's, and everything runs smooth again. The problem is not actiual polygon count, but number of objects in the scene. If you you use DWG link, then likely you have thousands as well.

In 2008 the display issues seem to be cleared up, although still not stellar performance in "complicated scenes", but at render time there is still a significant lag. This is unaceptable and a huge disspaointment on my end. I have several model files that will lag for 7-10 minutes everytime I hit render. Multiply that time 20, and 3 hours for my day is spent waiting fro max to compile geomtry. i I attach all the objects togetehr, then problem solved. However, I have to do this each and evey time there is a design change.

Why autodesk can't simply give us a fetaure in the DWG import that automates this is beyond me. 10 versions of this program and they still can not solve basic workflow issues. ADT and DWG link have created more problems than answers on our end. Anyone that remembers Vizrender and the architectural materials that Autodesk came up with is likely throwing on their keyboard reading this.

I am once again dissapointed by Autodesks claims,
I hear you too. Unfortunately, i dont think autodesk does enough to go out into the 3D community to see what the real workflow issues are. they say they spend a lot of time querying companies for issues to solve, but i would love to know what companies they are talking to that dont bring some of these issues up. case in point, for 6 months here on cga and numerous other websites, i advertised my new Max book with the title '3ds Max 10'...only after 6 months did someone at autodesk inform me that my using that title was a really really really bad thing that put autodesk at serious risk for some sort of SEC action lawsuit, and that i needed to remove the '10' in the title immediately. if autodesk had just one person monitoring some of these sites regularly, they would see bigger issues than those pointed out in their current research methods
__________________
Brian Smith
www.3dats.com
3D Architectural Training Solutions
Brian Smith is offline   Reply With Quote